• Press Release Text

    What is read is strange, what is seen uncanny

     

    Bona Park, Artist 

     

    When I asked Choe Sooryun for materials on her work in preparation for a text about her upcoming solo exhibition, she first sent me a file titled Threefold Translation, containing strange tales that she said she enjoyed reading. The file consisted of texts in three languages: the original Chinese, translated literally into English and Korean according to the artist’s own approach. These were stories that would feature in the works presented in her new exhibition. It was my first time reading classical Chinese tales of the strange (zhiguai), and I found it intriguing that their lack of a narrative structure based on cause and effect, along with their abrupt endings, felt unfamiliar, while at the same time evoking a curious familiarity, as though they were not so far removed from Korean folk tales and legends. What struck me in particular was how, in these tales, the worlds of the living and the dead were not clearly separated but remained interconnected, influencing one another, and how the logic of narrative progression was far from apparent.

     

    Choe subsequently showed me a work incorporating one of the stories I had read. By “incorporating” the story, I mean that the work brought together the original tale written in Chinese characters, a Korean text transcribed with readings and other annotations, and images that evoked the story. Three aspects of the work caught my attention. First, text, which Choe has been painting for many years, continued to occupy a substantial part of the composition. Second, the figurative images she painted did not, in fact, refer to any specific entities. Third, the work was structured as though another frame, containing a handwritten transcription, were nested within the larger frame of the painting.

     

    Since I had read the strange tales Choe sent me beforehand, I tried to identify which story the text in the painting referred to as soon as I saw the work. But as I began to make out the Korean characters, I realized that my attention was moving beyond comprehension, shifting instead to other parts of the painting. Unlike a document or a book, Choe’s text does not yield itself easily; it continually slips away. As I follow the characters in search of meaning, I soon find myself attending more closely to their colors, balance, and movement. My eye is drawn to the sensuous traces of characters that seem to have been written and erased several times, the way the neat forms of Korean script harmonize with images of an East Asian landscape, and the variations in emphasis conveyed by the fluorescent colors used to mark pronunciations. I also begin to notice the gentle flow of images extending in the direction of the text, as well as the subtle atmosphere that pervades the entire composition.

     

    In Choe’s paintings, text does not simply convey the content of a story. Rather, it sets the entire painting in motion. Her painted text is neither a secondary nor a decorative element that explains the images, but a sign through which the meaning of the work as a whole emerges. It can also be understood as painting in its own right. The way the writing gradually recedes from comprehension and comes into view as an image feels like a dynamic experience in which the eye repeatedly brings an indistinct object into and out of focus. By alternating between legibility and obscurity, the text makes Choe’s paintings all the more intriguing.

     

    It is not only the text that resists being fixed and clearly defined. The images Choe paints also continue to shimmer, as though stirred by a gentle breeze. The willows, peach trees, and lotus flowers within the frames are familiar motifs often encountered when thinking of China and Asia more broadly, making it difficult to connect them to any particular story. They are rendered so indistinctly that they resemble images on an old television with low resolution and static interference. Nor is there a clear visual hierarchy between these images and the forms or texts that appear almost like sketches outside the frame.In some paintings, even the creases of the paper or patterns drawn in the background pass across the images themselves. All these modes of expression suggest that the forms Choe paints are not intended to faithfully depict or point to anything in particular. One begins to sense that what she paints are not the trees in a story or the flowers of the actual world, but some unseen world. In this world, vague, fixed notions of stories and images, of the East and tradition, along with rigid definitions of painting and the logical ordering and separation of things, no longer hold their usual form. Instead, they seem to sway freely and fall into a loose disarray.

     

    Within the paper on which she paints, Choe draws another frame, one that also resembles a page copied from a zhiguai tale. Her act of transcribing these old Chinese stories with a brush brings to mind the concept of the palimpsest, used by the French literary critic Gérard Genette. Originally, a palimpsest referred to parchment on which new writing was inscribed after the original text had been erased or faded. The term derives from an ancient Greek word meaning “to write again.” Genette used it to describe a mode of creation in which an existing source serves as the basis for a new work, not through direct reproduction, but through transformation or imitation. In a palimpsest, the original is never entirely erased or lost; it continues to leave traces as it is reborn with new meanings.

     

    Like the image of the palimpsest, Choe’s paintings incorporating handwritten transcriptions preserve the original story while layering new meanings over it. In her work, the texts of classical Chinese tales are transformed into visual images and encountered as paintings within the space of an art exhibition. Viewers look at and read Choe’s painted text as a work of contemporary art, something that can be physically hung on a wall. As works of contemporary art, her paintings cross the boundaries between text and image, fiction and painting, tradition and the present, the visible and the invisible, while raising new questions about the distinctions and definitions that separate them and adding further layers of meaning. This is also akin to the way the world of zhiguai tales is constructed, with boundaries between humans and ghosts, reality and unreality, never clearly defined. Choe’s paintings of handwritten transcriptions thus create a palimpsestic state in which a new work is written over the original while preserving its traces. The Korean translations, rendered in a different color outside the frame, along with the readings of Chinese characters and the patterns and images that cross the frame, can likewise be understood as ways in which the artist actively brings her own pictorial world into contact with the ancient texts.

     

    Rather than showing something clearly, Choe’s paintings move subtly, oscillating between the visible and the invisible. The text in a painting becomes an image at one moment, while an image that seems to point to a concrete object dissolves once again into a vague notion of the East. Ancient Chinese tales, transcribed by hand, become paintings in the present, and traces of the original are layered over anew in the work. On the loosened boundaries between transcription and creation, text and image, fiction and painting, reality and unreality, tradition and the present, Choe’s paintings resist being fixed within a single definition. They repeatedly come into focus and fade from view, swaying before our eyes in a manner both uncanny and beautiful.

     

    *Among the Chinese zhiguai tales Choe Sooryun sent me, the story “Strange Song of Nie Bao” contains the phrase “The events are strange, and the words uncanny.” I was particularly taken with this sentence, as I felt that the adjectives “strange” and “uncanny” aptly captured the new sensory territory that Choe’s paintings seek to explore by crossing boundaries. Choe is currently preparing a book of the zhiguai tales she has retranslated.